Key West is an island in the straits of Florida that attracts all visitors, including water sports lovers, those wanting to explore nightlife, nature enthusiasts, and history buffs. Travelers can discover history and nature at Fort Zachary Taylor Historic State Park or party on Duval Street, with plenty of bars, nightclubs, and live music venues. Key West is also home to delicious Caribbean-inspired cuisines, including fresh seafood and shellfish. Those looking to get the most out of their trip can book these ten places to stay for dinner in Key West and indulge in island eats.

Our recommendations for the best places to stay for dinner in Key West are based on meticulously researching the best accommodations with restaurants in the Conch Republic. These places have high ratings and extensive menus to offer all travelers the best island dining experiences.

RELATED: Heading To The Keys: The Ultimate Guide To Key West & Things To Do There

Opal Key Resort & Marina

Opal Key Resort & Marina is a stylish waterfront resort in the heart of Key West, a few steps from Mallory Square and Duval Street. It is near major attractions such as Key West Aquarium, the Memory Sculpture, and the Key West Museum of Art and History. Guests enjoy luxurious accommodations in spacious rooms and suites with private balconies and modern furnishings and amenities. Visitors enjoy a diverse dining experience from any of the three waterfront restaurants in an outdoor setting. The Bistro 245 is open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, serving delicious appetizers, pasta, and island specialties like gries Ribeye and Key West Yellowtail Snapper.

RELATED: Where to Stay in Key West

Isla Bella Beach Resort

Isla Bella is a luxurious beach resort on the iconic Seven Mile Bridge on 24 acres of white sands and turquoise blue waters. Guests enjoy spacious rooms with modern bathrooms, exquisite bathroom amenities, contemporary art, floor-to-ceiling windows, and oversized terraces offering panoramic ocean views. The resort offers many exciting activities, including fishing, biking, and kayaking. Visitors can dine at Mahina, a Polynesian-inspired restaurant offering a mix of Hawaiian and regional cuisines.

The Marquesa Hotel

The Marquesa is a luxury boutique hotel in Key West that combines a casual restaurant with a modern hotel. Located at the center of the old town historic district, the hotel has beautifully restored conch houses with modern bathrooms, central air conditioning, telephones, refrigerators, ironing facilities, and hair dryers. A stay at this hotel would be complete with dining at the award-winning Cafe Marquesa, a local and international favorite. Guests enjoy grilled meat, fresh local seafood, appetizers, salads, and freshly baked bread. There is a cozy bar for drinks, dessert, light bites, and coffee.

The Saint Hotel Key West Autograph Collection

The Saint is a beautiful multi-stored hotel near historical museums, theaters, and art galleries along Duval Street. It combines a chic contemporary style with southern charm and a laid-back island style. The hotel has 171 guest rooms and provides genuine Southern hospitality in luxurious amenities, personal workspaces, and fiber optic Wi-Fi. An in-house restaurant operates from 7 am to 11 pm, offering various culinary options and a landscaped pool to offer a cooling rest from the day's activities.

RELATED: Uncover The Charm Of Key West: Your Guide To Duval Street & Beyond

The Galleon Resort & Marina

The Galleon is a vacation choice for solo travelers and families in Old Town Key West overlooking the Gulf of Mexico. It offers accommodation in penthouses, suites, and studios with kitchenettes, balconies, wet bars, and ironing facilities. The marina provides docking space for ships and yachts up to 150 feet. Visitors can dine at the Pirates Cove restaurant at the marina and enjoy views of boats and activities at Key West Harbor. They have access to the outdoor pool and a private beach in the Gulf of Mexico.

The Southernmost House

The Southernmost House is an adult-only boutique hotel near The Butterfly and Nature Conservancy in Key West. It has elegant rooms and suites with oversized beds, ample sitting and working areas, plush furnishings, small kitchens with refrigerators, and private patios. Guests dine at the Seaside Cafe, a family-owned and operated restaurant within the house grounds, a few steps from the Atlantic Ocean waters. The restaurant is known for its signature Molitos, wood-fired pizzas, and Honey Butter lobster biscuits.

Sunset Key Cottages

Sunset Key Cottages are luxurious vacation rentals on a private island with vibrant orchids and bougainvillea. It comprises two, three, and four-bedroom cottages with charming details and views to die for, a separate living area, kitchen, and bathroom. Guests enjoy seasonal flavors and ingredients at the Latitude restaurant, one of the best in Key West, inspired by warm breezes and gorgeous views. It serves dinner from 5 to 10 pm and has an extensive menu comprising entrees, appetizers, salads, and sweet endings.

RELATED: Best Places to Stay in Key West

H2O Suites Hotel

H2O Suites are luxury adult-only suites in Key West, a few steps from Dog Beach and Duval Street. Guests can relax by the sparkling pool, unwind at the rooftop deck while enjoying island-inspired drinks and breathtaking views, or spend romantic moments in the Key West Lighthouse at Sunset or shop at Duval Street. They can dine at Milagro Restaurant on the sister property and enjoy contemporary Latin cuisines artfully prepared by expert chefs.

RELATED: 10 Things To Do In Key West (That Don’t Involve Pie)

Hyatt Residence Club, Windward Pointe

Hyatt Residence Club is a home away from home in Key West, a few minutes from Mallory Square and the iconic Duval Street. It has spacious residential-style units with modern amenities for a convenient stay. The two-bedroom units have spacious dining areas, full kitchens, living rooms, and furnished balconies and offer partial ocean views. Guests can make their dinner at the convenience of their suites or eat at the Abbey Road shack that opens at 8 pm.

The Reach, Key West, Curio Collection by Hilton

The Reach is a boutique hotel in Key West near South Beach, Southernmost Point, Key West Lighthouse, The Basilica of St.Mary Star of The Sea, and Key West Butterfly and Nature Conservatory. It offers nautical-inspired beachfront rooms and suites with beautiful designs, stylish amenities, and panoramic Atlantic Ocean views. Guests enjoy island eats at the Four Marlins oceanfront dining casually. Dinner comprises freshly caught fish, seafood, desserts like Key Lime Pie, impressive wines, and thoughtfully crafted cocktails.